By using our website, you agree to the use of our cookies.

Supernatural “Thin Lizzie” 

Photo Credit: Katie Yu/The CW

Supernatural Season 11 is rolling along quite nicely, don’t you guys think? I enjoyed “Thin Lizzie” way more than I thought I would. It had the feel of a classic episode but it was so much more. I think it turned out to be exactly what I’ve always wanted for this show. It’s a Monster of the Week investigation coupled with strong ties to Mythology. It’s a friggin’ hybrid of an episode and I loved every bit of it. Take that, ghoul-pires!

What else did it have going for it? Let’s break things down.

“Thin Lizzie” — Totally adored the title. It’s a play on the Irish rock band, Thin Lizzy. This show knows itself. And as much as the monsters and the car and the brothers are a part of Supernatural, so is the music. Whether it’s in the soundtrack or the titles of episodes or the aliases the boys take on as federal agents (in this case, Agents Collins and Gabriel. Sorry, Misha. Sam wasn’t referring to you. This was all about Genesis.)

Photo Credit: Katie Yu/The CW
Photo Credit: Katie Yu/The CW

The Guest Stars — especially Jared Gertner‘s Len — were wonderful. Len’s interactions with the Winchesters are funny, quirky and, ultimately, heartbreaking. I’d love to see him again. Maybe there can be another case in a jail someday a la “Folsom Prison Blues?” The girl playing Amara is great, too. Unfortunately, we won’t be seeing too much of her again since Amara’s a quickly growing girl thanks to her soul-sucking ways. On IMDB, she is down as appearing in next week’s “Our Little World.”

The Soulless Game — I like that we’re revisiting what it means to be soulless in this universe. Gosh, was it really five seasons ago that Soulless Sam ruled our hearts? This topic has been touched on since those days, but now that Amara’s doing the soul-sucking thing, it’s back in full force. And I like that people react differently to losing their essence. For Len, he knows what he should be doing and feeling and loving (i.e. his Lizzie Borden obsession). But none of it gives him enjoyment anymore.

However, he doesn’t turn into a “whack” job like Sydney does. Len wants his soul back so bad. Sydney’s soullessness turns out to be her salvation (and her undoing). She feels free because she’s no longer burdened with pesky feelings. The emotional pain from the abuse she experienced in her childhood — gone. It does, however, turn her into a cold-blooded killer. Those thoughts were there before. Now she has no conscience holding her back. I guess you can consider her a kidnapper as well. She gets the drop on the boys but good and props them up all nice and pretty for Amara.

Thankfully, Sam escapes his ropes and Len comes to the rescue. Once again, I have to say how much I enjoyed that guy. He doesn’t want to off anyone. He’s tremendously self-aware with his new condition. He can feel a darkness bubbling up within himself and knows he’ll kill again. Since Sam and Dean are all about saving people with minimal collateral damage these days, the older Winchester’s not going to take matters in his own hands. He doesn’t have to. Len decides to take himself out of the equation. Not by killing himself — he decides to confess to all the murders and turns himself in. What a classy, kind of weird, totally awesome guy. So sad this happens to him, however. I kind of got emotional simply thinking of what’s ahead for him.

Photo Credit: Katie Yu/The CW

Sam and Dean — I continue to enjoy the brothers working together this season. Their banter is awesome. They tease each other so beautifully. And I really adore their lean-against-Baby bro moment at the end of the episode. Of course, I can’t get enough of soul-searching Winchester BMs. Sue me.

Sam’s True Crime fascination — I like that the show has continued to showcase his fascination with the macabre. There are so many quirks to Dean that we know about. I’m happy the show hasn’t forgotten about Sam being a serial killer buff. His calling the Lizzie Borden room is in character and so much fun, as twisted as this sounds.

Dean’s expressions — Reacting to the doily-fied hotel room at the Lizzie Borden Inn or when Len quickly accepts he has no soul — Dean’s expressions are classic and entertain me verily. Keep them coming, Jensen.

Amara — At the end of “Thin Lizzie,” when Sam and Dean drive away, we see Amara who says: “Bye, Dean. I’ll see you soon.” NICE MOMENT. And so scary. It’s really cool how they’re threading her through these episodes.

While it felt like things took a little bit to advance to the good stuff, I really enjoyed everything that happened in “Thin Lizzie.” Kudos to the new writer, Nancy Won. OMG. Just took a look at her credits. She’s written/produced for shows I’ve watched like Everwood, Brothers and Sisters, Dirty Sexy Money and Being Human, a series Supernatural head honcho Jeremy Carver co-created that used to run on Syfy. Not going to lie, as much as I loved Being Human, I’m most impressed with Won’s Dirty, Sexy, Money credit. I am not worthy. Anyway, hope she’ll be back with more later this season.

And I also hope this week’s director — Rashaad Ernesto Green — will be back. He did another seamless job with “Thin Lizzie.” If you recall, he was new to this world in Season 10 when he directed “Inside Man.” Here’s to him getting a couple more opportunities to put his stamp on Supernatural this season.

Before I call it quits on this recap, here’s more from Jensen and Jared’s Vancouver Set Interview. First, Jensen and Jared talk Amara. And then in the second video, I got the chance to ask Jensen about Dean meeting Billie the Reaper from Season 11’s “Form and Void.”

One final note: Yay to Eric Kripke FINALLY joining Twitter! Supernatural airs Wednesdays at 9/8c on the CW.

Related posts


  1. MByerly

    Did you pick up on Dean’s look toward the woods before they left as if he knew Amara was there, or was that just my imagination?

    1. Tina Charles

      I did not. I’m going to have to take another look. Interesting…

  2. Denise

    Yes, I picked up on that look toward the woods as well. It’s got me looking forward to next week. Loved Jensen saying how they all were impressed with Lisa Berry’s performance as the reaper and wanted to get her back for more.

    1. Tina Charles

      Now I’m really going to have to rewatch that moment if you picked up on it as well.

      By the way, I was the one that asked about Dean getting a chance to meet the reaper so I was super happy with the answer. She was awesome in her scene with Jared. Plus, her voice was amazing. Now I need to see her come face to face with Dean. Thanks for reading and commenting!

  3. Teri

    I missed the look towards the woods as well. Did you rewatch it yet Tina? I’m going to have to do that ASAP.

    Every episode this season has been great. I look forward to each week like I used to in the beginning. BTW, I lol every time I think of Dean saying “say it with me!” when talking about the ghoul-pires and other hybrid baddies. 🙂

    1. Tina Charles

      Jensen even said “say it with me” in the video interview I was a part of when I went to Vancouver. I don’t think I posted it yet!
      I’m loving this season so far. HOPE it continues.
      And I still have to go back and watch that last shot. LOL

Leave a Reply

Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.