[Warning: General spoilers ahead.]
Alison Sweeney is back at The Cookie Jar (in a brand new location that makes for a fun twist on a murder board) Friday night for her 10th outing as Hannah Swensen. In “A Sprinkle of Deceit,” a catering job for Lonnie’s reunion sets up her involvement in yet another murder investigation when he becomes the prime suspect in a classmate’s death. And as her sister, Michelle’s, bae, Hannah is not about to let him take the fall for something he did not do.
That of course runs her right into the crosshairs of the new DA, Chad (a returning Victor Webster). This time, however, the Sheriff (Mike Dopud) gently suggests that Chad let her do her thing because she gets results, and finds ways in to gather clues that they can’t.
I spoke with Sweeney this week about the film, and her upcoming Christmas movie,This Time Each Year, which airs in three weeks–marking her 30th title between Hallmark Channel and Hallmark Mystery. I’ll have the second part of interview for closer to its airdate. Up first, we talk about all things Lake Eden.

Sweeney is an executive producer on the series, and she also wrote the most recent film, “One Bad Apple.” With “A Sprinkle of Deceit,” she handed the reins to a pair of writers who would bring a different POV and she loved their take on Hannah’s world.
“[Nick Hopkins and Tim James] are these two wonderful British guys who are a team and they write together. And it was just a fun opportunity to get to hire them and get a chance to bring their vibe to Hannah. And they write British mysteries, so I was thrilled to talk with them and bring that quirky British humor and sentiment and then the really good clues and crime solving. I loved what they brought to the story,” she says.
“They really thought through those clues and went about it in a way that is sort of unexpected. What I hope, what my main goal of these movies is, is that I want people to enjoy it the second time, the third time they watch it, and understand other clues and see other parts of it that they hadn’t put together before. So things that come through the next time you watch it, you’ll see what we layered in underneath.”
“One of the things I loved about the reunion was that it was just this great party atmosphere. So people are kind of acting their best and you’re left looking at these people you just met and wondering, ‘Who’s gonna die? Who’s gonna be the murderer? Are they even at this party?’ It was a lot of fun.”

The film also brings in the youngest witness to date, a young boy who lives next door to the victim and who knows exactly how long a suspect was in the house because he was making a midnight snack that took six minutes to prepare. “That was from the book [Coconut Layer Cake Murder]. And I just loved the idea,” shares Sweeney.
“It was such a clever clue that Joanne Fluke wrote of how a car gets described. And then, the shoe dropping for Hannah when she realized the mistake she made and part of that is to do with baking. She might never have figured that out if not for her own skill set at the bakery. “
“I definitely wanted it in the movie. And then to have these things with the kid. You”re sort of thinking to yourself, ‘What’s he doing up at midnight? Let’s talk about that.’ And luckily I have one, I used to have two, in my house who would do things like that. You hear them rummaging around at 12 o’clock at night and you’re like, ‘Why are you eating again?'”
“So that was one hundred percent something my kids would do. And he’s just one of those precocious kids who, if he’s gonna do it, he’s going to invent his own recipes. And I just thought that was so great. What a great way for Hannah and this kid to have a bond. He’s a kindred spirit.”

“And then I thought, ‘People who bake or cook, know [that if a recipe takes] six minutes, then you better do it right.’ So he knew exactly how long [the suspect] was in that house because it was exactly six minutes. It’s such a perfect way of capturing time, even for a kid. So I just thought all of those clues really worked out. And Denzel Onaba was just a great little actor and it made it all a fun twist.”
Over the last few years, Hallmark has ramped up the wink-nod by having other members of the Hallmarkies community pop in for cameos, and Hannah Swensen gets in on the game with a very, very funny drop by that I will not spoil. Sweeney was thrilled to have her friend come play. “She’s brilliant. She’s so funny. So originally, as you can imagine, that was not meant to be a speaking role,” she explains.
“We were trying to figure it out and I realized it’s the beginning of the movie, and it needs a little oomph, especially because of where it takes Dolores in the storyline. So the more I read it, the more I thought, ‘Here we are in Vancouver and I know several actresses that are up here filming…wouldn’t it be funny to get someone, a Hallmark person, to come do a cameo for us in that role?”
“And I pitched it to Hallmark, and of course they love the idea. And I happened to know an actress in my mind, who happened to be in town. And I called my friend first and said, ‘What are you doing on Friday?’ And she said, ‘That’s a weird question. I’m prepping a movie.’ And I asked if she was filming and she said not until Monday.”

And I said, ‘Have I got a good idea…’ And it was so funny because I originally texted it to her and she didn’t reply right away. I totally love that I’m telling this story. And hours went by and I thought, ‘Oh my gosh, I offended her in some way. I didn’t ask politely or I just assumed she would like the idea. What if she doesn’t like the idea?’ I was just staring at my phone wondering why she hadn’t written me back.”
“And then finally hours later, she wrote me back that she was getting a facial or something, and she had to put her phone down. And so she just hadn’t seen her phone in hours. And I said, ‘Do you know what I have been through thinking that you weren’t replying to me?'”
“We were laughing so hard. We had such a great giggle about it. But then she shows up on set, she killed it and it was so funny. And she just had all these great, funny lines and ad libs and we just kept the whole thing in and just really made a meal out of her being there with us. I just loved it. It was so funny. She’s the best.”
“We love actors, and love making fun of actors. We get such a kick out of that opportunity. And then you know, Barbara [Niven], Victor, and I are all standing there watching. The three of us could hardly keep a straight face. There were plenty of outtakes where we said, ‘Stop, do a normal one one time so we can react normal.'”

“The other one that kills me is the scene’s still going on and the director comes and gets Dolores and then takes her hand and leads her on set and she immediately becomes Vivian Leigh. All of a sudden she’s a glam star from the forties. And she lights up the screen all the time, but that character is really becoming the star of the movie.”
A Sprinkle of Deceit: A Hannah Swensen Mystery premieres Friday, October 4, at 9 pm/8c on Hallmark Mystery and streaming on various outlets in the US. I’ll update when I hear about a Canadian outlet. In case you missed it, my 10th interview with Victor Webster, previewing the film, is available here.
Photos courtesy of Bettina Strauss for Hallmark Media; video courtesy of Hallmark Media.