After what feels like eons of waiting, we all finally got the chance to devour Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life this past weekend. With all the anticipation surrounding it, it feels like a serious comedown after the fact. On top of that, Iâ€™m surprised that the revival left me so emotionally drained. I never considered Gilmore Girls that kind of show. In fact, I considered it the opposite, something light and uplifting to make your feel better when youâ€™re emotionally drained. The revival was definitely different than I expected, but Iâ€™ve had some time to process and itâ€™s clear that there were parts of Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life that worked beautifully and the parts that didn’t at all.
Lorelaiâ€™s storyline: I think this may be a testament to Lauren Grahamâ€™s devotion to Lorelai Gilmore as a character, but Lorelaiâ€™s arc was much stronger than Roryâ€™s in A Year in the Life. I was always interested in Roryâ€™s life in the original Gilmore Girls, but Lorelaiâ€™s existential breakdown felt so much more significant than Roryâ€™s, and it was believable, so it worked. At 48 years old, Lorelaiâ€™s options really are dwindling. The show approached the idea of childbearing slipping through your fingertips, mostly due to poor communication, with aplomb. Even if the solutions to Lorelaiâ€™s problems were exceedingly simple (duh, marry your live-in boyfriend of a decade, oh look hereâ€™s building for sale exactly the right size for an expanded Dragonfly!) it was fun to watch. And Lauren Graham and Kelly Bishop are electric on-screen, which leads to my next â€œyes, this definitely worked.â€
Mourning Richard/Emilyâ€™s storyline: It feels like everything surrounding Richardâ€™s death was actually the point of A Year in the Life. Everything else could have been left out and we would have had a gorgeous, painful standalone story. And the blowout that Lorelai and Emily have is the rawest, most emotionally charged moments of the series. And those Emily/Lorelai scenes are often some of the best scenes in the original series as well. Emily Gilmore is such a nuanced character, and I think in many ways more compelling than Lorelai and Rory. Seeing her deal with Richardâ€™s death and then embrace change was practically life-affirming. I would have never imagined Emily Gilmore, Museum Docent as something that I would ever want to see, but it was absolutely perfect. All the pieces of her transformation were on point, from changing the headstone fives times (Girl, I feel the same way about singe quotes) all the way to changing into sneakers, and her peace at the end felt so earned.
Emotional beats: Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life was a much more serious affair than the original Gilmore Girls. This could have led to melodrama, but luckily, for the most part the major emotional moments land, and land big. Iâ€™m not a TV crier. I never got misty-eyed during Parenthood or Everwood. But Iâ€™ll be damned if I wasnâ€™t feeling some things ate end of â€œSummer.â€ The scene with Sutton Foster singing and Lorelai realizing how lost she is and what she has to do to rectify the situation was stunning. I even got strangely sad during the Rory/Dean scene! And the spur-of-the-moment nighttime wedding between Luke and Lorelai was as perfect as any fan could have asked for, save for some key missing characters (Emily, Sookie, and Jess not showing for this? But Laneâ€™s there?), it was a great ode to the relationship. And although Iâ€™m not going to discuss my actual opinions on the last four words here, the final scene of the series, with Lorelai and Rory sitting on the gazebo steps in the early morning hours, was perfectly sweet, then bittersweet, before turning panicked. Alexis Bledel and Lauren Graham nailed the look that they give each other at the very end.
Roryâ€™s storyline: Oh wow, where to begin with this. Very little of Roryâ€™s story landed for me. There have been plenty of articles over the years about how â€œRory is the worstâ€ and the storylines in the revival amplified the problematic aspects of Roryâ€™s character. Starting a casual relationship with the guy who proposed to you and you turned down is downright cold. And while in a committed relationship with another guy for over two years who you treat like trash? Unbelievable. And when she finds out that Logan is engaged, she continues on, seemingly content to be his mistress until he has the audacity to relegate her to a hotel when she visits to pick up their affair. Watching A Year in the Life, all I could think of was that Iâ€™m actually on #TeamNotRory. The only one of Roryâ€™s love interests that comes out on top is Dean, because was actually able to get away from her and have a happy life. This was a literal text exchange between me and my sister while watching:
Me: All of Roryâ€™s bfs aged like fine wine
Sister: Yes indeed
Me: Also, Iâ€™m like y’all need to get tf away from Rory cuz sheâ€™s poison and you can do better
Sister: God I hate them all. All the Gilmore.
Complaints about Roryâ€™s treatment of others aside, the idea that she had spent somewhere around nine years floundering around the journalism world doesnâ€™t seem very believable. And would the Rory Gilmore who hounded the editor of the Stamford-Eagle Gazette everyday for a week to get him to look at her clips really come strangely unprepared when meeting with Conde Nast? It felt out of character and it just seemed like a story that should have happened when she was in her mid-twenties, not 32.
I appreciated the idea of an aimless Rory, since itâ€™s so true to life for many young people, but Iâ€™d argue we got plenty of that in the original. I would have loved more focus on her mourning her grandfather, since Rory and Richard did have a close relationship. But thereâ€™s very little time spent on it, other than when she walks through her grandparents home before beginning her book in Richardâ€™s study. It was a missed opportunity, especially since Richardâ€™s work ethic was frequently what drove Rory to push harder during her time at Yale.
Quirky Interludes: â€œSummerâ€ and â€œFallâ€ both include lengthy non-plot relevant bits that I am referring to as â€œquirky interludes.â€ In â€œSummerâ€ we have the Sutton Foster-led musical, which while certainly funny as itâ€™s own isolated thing, is boring and tedious in the episode. I actually skipped it all together when watching â€œSummer,â€ only to watch it the next day when I wasnâ€™t exhausted from already watching three hours of Gilmore Girls. Itâ€™s a very funny piece! But my god, it would have been significantly better if it had been a quarter of the length. Itâ€™s also the kind of think that Lorelai would love, at least ironically, instead she criticizes it heavily.
In â€œFallâ€ we have to sit through a nearly fifteen-minute block of Rory running around with the washed-up Life and Death Brigade. The beginning, with the strange clues and hazy air (very Pretty Little Liars with the set and all) was fun, but the rooftop golfing and the foray into the tango club and then on to New Hampshire was exhausting. I also think Life and Death Brigade Rory is my least favorite iteration, since this was the era where she was the most entitled, careless, and unlikable. And itâ€™s kind of funny when a 25-year-old with no concept of the value of money buys a club, but a 35-year-old doing it is sad. Plus, there was something undeniably Mystery the Pickup Artist-esque about their ensembles. But I was happy to see the characters again, though as with the musical in â€œSummer,â€ the length could have easily been cut with better results.
Length: Even though they are twice as long as a typical Gilmore Girls episode, the 90-minute long features donâ€™t actually work that well as standalone stories. There arenâ€™t really beginnings, middles, and ends. Itâ€™s as if these were created to be binge-watched. But with the amount of time covered in the series, it feels like significant portions of the story are missing, which is especially noticeable when watching the episodes back-to-back. The longer length also sucked humor out of the show, since tightness is important for the type of humor Gilmore Girls plays with. We also just had so much story to fit into six hours, and so although each episode was long, we didnâ€™t actually get the space to let the characters breathe. Some of the best moments of Gilmore Girls happen with a longer bit of silence, rare in a show so focused on dialogue. I just wanted the moments to be longer. Emily on the beach, Lorelai on in the faux-wilderness, Rory sitting at her grandfatherâ€™s desk. Just an extra beat would have hoped, though I do count these scenes as some of the good ones of the series. But they could have been exalted.
Whatâ€™s up for debate:
Roryâ€™s book. I rolled my eyes when I got a glimpse of the title of Roryâ€™s book, since the idea of a character writing a book about what has happened over the course of a show is so incredibly derivative at this point. But at least she didnâ€™t have Doyle turn it into a script? That said, although it was clichÃ©, it didnâ€™t actually bother me that much in the moment. It doesnâ€™t seem entirely out of left field that Rory attempt to write a book when her journalism career was failing. I did find Lorelaiâ€™s reaction bizarre, since sheâ€™s never been the type to hide facets of her life. Hell, this is the woman who called her mother Pol Pot in an interview with a magazine. Lorelai is frequently shown as being a bit narcissistic (seriously, her firing all of the chefs? What a ridiculous, mean-spirited, selfish thing to do), and what narcissist wouldnâ€™t want a book written about them? Was it a good narrative choice to create a rift between Rory and Lorelai because of a book idea that the ever narcissistic Lorelai? It did push Roryâ€™s meandering story to a finish line, but Iâ€™m not sure if it was the best tactic.
Jess looking through the window. Iâ€™ve owned up to being a Jess/Rory OTP kind of person, so on one hand, this gave me hope. Logan is to Rory as Christopher is to Lorelai (the guy you canâ€™t quit, but should), so Jess is Luke (the guy whoâ€™s been pining for you all along and will make you happy). But in on the other hand, Jess looking all heartbreakingly through the window at Rory bummed me out big time. They havenâ€™t been an item since they were teenagers. And the last memory we have of them together is Rory using Jess as a piece of a revenge plan to get back at Logan. Jess, you are a smart, attractive, successful man. Go find someone who will treat you right. #TeamNotRory.
The final four words. I hated them when I heard them. I had a moment when I thought the entire show was ruined. But after getting a little space, I understand what the creators were getting at. Part of me wonders if this is a huge mistake, like a How I Met Your Mother type of misreading of what should happen with a planned ending. But that part of me is shrinking. The verdict is still out, but initial negative reaction is tempering.
It was far from perfect, but regardless of the missteps, I legitimately liked watching Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. Iâ€™m impressed by the heft of the revival. I warned against anything too ambitious since the less serious Gilmore Girls is, the more it works for me, but I have a lot of respect for the direction Amy Sherman-Palladino decided to take. And one thingâ€™s for sure, I havenâ€™t been able to stop thinking about it since I finished, which says a lot about the impression itâ€™s left on me.
Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life is streaming on Netflix now.
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Maahra Hill Talks The Irrational
I’m a Jesse L. Martin stan back to the OG Mothership Law & Order (pour one out for Lennie Brisco, y’all), although I admittedly tapped out on The Flash at a certain point. This season, Martin has been back in his old NBC stomping grounds with The Irrational, a different,…
George R. Olson, Tim Rozon, and Sarah Levy Talk the SurrealEstate S2 Finale
[Spoilers for the SurrealEstate Season 2 finale.] How’s everyone doing after the finale? As we close out the second season of SurrealEstate, some of our merry band of misfits are scattering to the winds–Zooey to law school, Phil to the Vatican, and Augie back to his think tank with Rochelle,…
Previewing SurrealEstate Season 2 Finale + Revisiting the Season with George R. Olson
[Warning; General spoilers ahead.] Strap in, SurrealEstate fam, because we’ve arrived at the Season 2 finale, and it’s a doozy. As we saw in the closing moments of last week’s episode, Susan is back. But because we have one more episode left, it’s not as simple as all that, as…
Tyler Hynes Talks Through His Eight-Film Hallmark Holiday Library
Things you realize when you have to re-record your shows on a new DVR – just how many Hallmark movies your people have done. Fan favorite – and one of ours – Tyler Hynes has done eight Christmas movies for Hallmark Channel and Hallmark Movies & Mysteries since 2018. Alongside…
Spencer Creaghan Talks About Creating SurrealEstate’s Signature Sound
SurrealEstate is winding down its second season, with two episodes left, and just as in Season 1, Spencer Creaghan’s music continues to be a character unto itself. And every week, he shares tidbits with the fans via his s social media channels, something he started to help give them an…
Andrew Walker Talks Christmas Island and the Magical Hallmark Community
[Warning: Spoilers for Christmas Island.] Now that the Screen Actors Guild strike has been resolved, we’re able to resume regularly scheduled programming and interview our favorites and yours. Up first, earlier today, I spoke with Andrew Walker about Christmas Island, which premiered last weekend and encores tonight and through the…
George Olson and Danishka Esterhazy Talk SurrealEstate “I Put a Spell on You”
[Warning: Spoilers for the episode.] Tonight’s fun new SurrealEstate found Luke caught up in an especially bewitching woman, Kay, played by Tara Yelland, Susan trapped in her house, and Zooey learning the ropes. In the next part of my conversation with showrunner George R. Olson and producing director Danishka Esterhazy,…
Danishka Esterhazy Talks SurrealEstate: “The Butler Didn’t”
[Warning: General spoilers for the episode]. Tonight’s new SurrealEstate, “The Butler Didn’t,” follows the team as they investigate the years-earlier mysterious death of a woman whose ghost now reenacts her hanging by dropping over the banister from the second floor to terrify anyone on the landing or at the bottom…
Scott McCord and Elizabeth Saunders Talk the From Season 2 finale
[Warning: Spoilers for the season finale.] How’s everyone doing after that finale? While we wait and wonder and hope for a third season announcement, soon, here’s what Scott McCord and Elizabeth Saunders had to say about their parts of the finale, and where they hope they get to go next….
Scott McCord and Elizabeth Saunders Talk From Season 2 + A Season Finale Preview
[Warning: General spoilers ahead.] It all comes down this, #FROMily. As Sunday’s episode wraps up Season 2, we begin with the aftermath of the terrifying onset of seemingly simultaneous attacks on Julie, Marielle, and Randall, which accelerate the “We gotta get out of this place” of it all. Sara comes…
What They Said: Three Revealing Conversations from Survivor’s Remorse “Closure”
WARNING: Spoilers for Survivor’s Remorse “Closure” The latest episode of Starz’s Survivor’s Remorse featured conversations that showed characters really digging deep into their thoughts, emotions and motivations.
Two Takes: The Catch “The Knock-Off”
Who can you trust? If this episode of The Catch was any indication, the answer is just about nobody. Betrayal was running rampant as Felicity (Shivani Ghai) arose from the dead to seduce-con Margot, Gretchen (Maria Thayer, Gotham, The Mindy Project) played gold-hearted Alice 2.0 before swindling Ethan, Tessa jumped…
What They Said: Top 3 Quotable Moments from Preacher “El Valero”
Both Quincannon and Jesse refuse to give up on what they each think is rightfully theirs. While Jesse is struggling to face the consequences of his actions, Quincannon has laid his past demons to rest and is hellbent on moving forward and putting Annville on the map again. Despite a…
What They Said: Favorite Quotes from Supergirl “Worlds Finest”
Oh, Supergirl. That ending was cold. But I can’t hate on you because the latest episode has quickly become one of my favorites.
What They Said: Top 4 Quotable Moments from Black Sails “XXIII”
The dialogue in “XXIII” is phenomenal. It’s always a fun ride when Black Sails carries its viewers along without giving them the chance to catch their breath. When an episode moves at this unforgiving pace, there is no chance for a breather nor is there a respite from the information…
What Lucifer Said: Favorite quotes from Supernatural “O Brother, Where Art Thou?”
Supernatural episodes are almost always funny but thanks to the dialogue and a certain man speaking said dialogue, I laughed a lot during “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” You know, when I wasn’t busy fearing for Sam’s life or wondering what in the world was going on with Dean and…
What They Said: The Flash, “Legends Of Today” and Arrow, “Legends Of Yesterday”
Two nights of Arrow +Â The Flash = what more could we ask for?! I don’t know what it is about blending these shows, but I canâ€™t help but feel that every time they come together, they somehow become greater than the sum of their parts. And thatâ€™s saying a lot…
What they Said: Top 4 Quotable Moments from Graceland “Little Bo Bleep”
Shoot outs. Fake outs. And long-awaited revelations. “Little Bo Bleep” was a jam-packed episode that wrapped up some loose ends and totally frayed others. Â It finally gave us one Sarkissian in jail and pulled back the curtain on Briggs’ master plan, but it also set up Jakes for a world…
What They Said: Favorite Quotes from Poldark “Part 4”
â€œWhat have I told you, I don’t require my wife to crochet and sip tea, but I do require her to remember she’s not a beast of burden.â€ No, Iâ€™m not talking about The Rolling Stones! I have to admit though, just for a second, the lyrics popped into my…
3 Moments of Goodness from Brooklyn Nine-Nine “Johnny and Dora”
The most satisfying part of this season’s finale has to the Jake and Amy kiss. Well, they kiss three times but the last one is the best one — and it means something. The Charles and Rosa dynamic was also great. I love how she’s convinced he doesn’t know anything…