Itâ€™s hard to believe, but weâ€™ve had almost a decade to mull over what became of the Gilmore Girls and all of those who orbited them. Maybe you imagined Luke and Lorelai lived happily ever after with twins, like that weird dream she had in season three. Maybe you imagined Rory regretted saying no to Loganâ€™s proposal and left her unfulfilling job as the metro editor at the Hartford Courant to follow him to California (Ha! Yeah, right). Or maybe you imagined Rory and Jess realized they were always meant to be together after they reunited at Luke and Lorelaiâ€™s wedding (OK, guilty as charged for this one. #TeamJess).
For better or for worse, the promos for the Netflix revival, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, have solved a lot of outstanding mysteries. When the series ended in 2007, after a much maligned final season without showrunners Amy Sherman-Palladino and Daniel Palladino, we were left with Rory going off to cover the Obama campaign, suggestions of a Luke and Lorelai reconciliation, and Emily and Richard finally giving Lorelai the respect she always wanted. But weâ€™re pretty sure it wasnâ€™t necessarily the Palladinosâ€™ vision. Enter this new entry into the Gilmore Girls canon. Iâ€™m being very calm and measured about this, but let me be clear-â€” Iâ€™m stupid excited to see where this show was supposed to end up.
However, not to be a killjoy, but with revivals being all the rage these days, and with their historically uneven quality, Iâ€™m not going in thinking this is going to be complete wish fulfillment. Itâ€™s easy to be blinded by the obvious excitement of your favorite show coming back and end up ignoring the huge risk of it all. Remember Arrested Development? Or The X-Files? The Veronica Mars movie? Or, heaven help us, the Heroes reboot? So, people, Iâ€™m kind of nervous.
Just recently, reviews for the new Gilmore Girls episodes have come out, and although the reviews are careful to keep mum about any plot points, overall the reception has been mixed. Judging by other revivals Iâ€™ve watched, I have some specific fears about Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. Luckily, Iâ€™m not one to criticize before seeing something for myself (except the Veronica Mars movie, which was actually really well received by critics, but my best friend who I watched the series with texted me saying the movie was awful so that was the end of it for me because Iâ€™m a pathetic joiner.)
Here are things that I think about when I hear about a revival:
Quality of the original
Expectation of genre
Promos and cast buy-in
Quality of the original
Gilmore Girls was an excellent series. When the show got everything right, it was incomparable in its warmth, character dynamics, and humor. Great source material is a big pro on my proverbial Rory Gilmore pro/con list, and Gilmore Girls, especially the first half of the series, had plenty of that.
Unfortunately, the show lost quality as it progressed, and I fear the last we saw of the show is the baseline of quality to expect for the new episodes. We could write off the middling end of the series as the lack of Sherman-Palladino, but thatâ€™s not an entirely fair assessment. It would be dishonest not to admit that there were obvious weak spots in the Palladino-run seasons, season six in particular.
With the train wreck that was April (didnâ€™t we already have a teen try to keep Lorelai and Luke apart? Ahem, Jess?) and the painful half-season long split between Rory and Lorelai, Season 6 wasnâ€™t necessarily bad, but it was arduous. And whatâ€™s to say those weak spots combined with the obvious difficulty of recreating a cult status show isnâ€™t going to lead to a huge disappointment?
Essentially, whatâ€™s to say that Season 6 quality isnâ€™t the norm here, considering it was the last we saw of the Palladinos? Iâ€™m probably a bit more generous than other regarding the sixth season, in that I actually like the basic concept of a major rift occurring between Lorelai and Rory. Iâ€™m just not crazy about the execution, nor the fact that the reconciliation never really feels true, all the way to the end of the series. And maybe thatâ€™s just fact of life, that youâ€™ll never be close with your family and friends like you were when you were young, but it hurts us too. But that gives me a bit of hopeâ€” maybe this revival is the chance to really see the Gilmore Girls back together again.
Moving on the structure: itâ€™s critical to how TV shows work. Changing episode lengths or the structural patterns can throw everything off. This was a major problem I had with the Arrested Development revival. The move from 22 minutes to 30 minutes for a straight comedy was terrible. The episodes dragged. They were boring. Dull. Every minor annoyance was magnified. Consequently, the extended length of the Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life episodes is a red flag for me. An early review from Alan Sepinwall of UPROXX confirmed my fear: he reports that the longer episodes do nothing to help our story. Iâ€™m concerned that the move from 42 minute episodes to 90 minute mini-movies will flanderize our characters and amplify the bad. Optimistically, maybe it could also amplify the good.
Expectation of genre
However, in terms of genre expectations, weâ€™re in much better shape than other revivals. For one, Gilmore Girls was a show where not much happened. Thereâ€™s no pressure to maintain the twists in a more suspenseful thriller or sci-fi show. Itâ€™s also not a straight comedy where jokes can feel stale or specific interactions are necessary for a gag. If Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life is a relatively low-key, if emotionally-driven affair, the highest stakes being Rory dealing with unemployment or Lorelai helping Emily reorganize her house after Richardâ€™s death, we might be in for something satisfying. I also think grounding the new episodes in Stars Hollow would be an excellent decision, since much of the later seasons of Gilmore Girls felt hollow, no pun intended, without the brightness that all the townies brought to seasons one through three.
Promos and cast buy-in
When the first full length trailer for A Year in the Life came out, I was in the â€œcautiously optimisticâ€ group. All the big notes seemed to be hit, nothing too gimmicky, etc. But there were some cringe-y moments in the trailer that I canâ€™t ignore. Lorelai hiking? It feels a bit too close to the scene where Rory and Lorelai play racquetball in the Season 7 premiere, â€œThe Long Morrow.â€ Or worse, when Rory claims â€œwe like to hit the gym when weâ€™re hereâ€ in one of my least favorite non-season seven episodes of the series, â€œA Vineyard Valentineâ€ (though at least Rory and Lorelai do just drink cucumber water and get massages when theyâ€™re at the gym).
However, Iâ€™m so pleased that the newest promos, including a longer teaser which includes Lorelai and Rory hazily listing all the types of food they ordered the night before and the super short teasers where Scott Patterson tells us Lukeâ€™s has new menus, have been delightful.
And that brings me to number three: cast buy-in. Everyone seems legitimately stoked to be doing this show again. Sure, theyâ€™re actors and theyâ€™re supposed to seem happy and promote their work, but you can tell when someone isnâ€™t proud of their movie or show. Itâ€™s a simple thing, but if the cast is excited, I feel excited. A full cast returning also means a better chance of recreating the chemistry that worked so well in the original series. Revivals without lots of returning cast canâ€™t always rely on what worked before; with almost the entire cast returning, weâ€™re in very good shape for Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life.
Itâ€™s funny, but I think my deep attachment to Gilmore Girls is forcing me to remain skeptical on some level, presumably to prevent disappointment. But truly, even with my concerns laid out, I donâ€™t doubt that fans, myself included, will love this experience. Gilmore Girls was a magical show for a lot of people, the kind of show you bonded with people over. Honestly, if the feelings associated with it can be evoked again and if the heart of this show is still present in these new episodes, weâ€™ll already be there. Copper boom.
Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life lands on Netflix this Friday, Nov. 25.
We’re Back Featurette
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Dennis Heaton Talks The Imperfects
Longtime readers at TV Goodness will know that Motive is one of my ride-or-die series, and as such, I am fiercely loyal to its creator, Dennis Heaton. He followed up that fantastic reverse procedural with Netflix’s The Order and is back on our streaming screens with The Imperfects, which dropped…
Kelly McCormack Talks Favorite Moments in A League of Their Own
[Warning: Mild spoilers for season 1.] Now that you’ve had a chance to watch A League of Their Own, here’s the rest of my chat with Kelly McCormack about her favorite moments of the season. Seeing the iconic Peaches uniforms for the first time wasn’t just a goosebump moment for…
John Griffin and Harold Perrineau Talk From on EPIX Season 1 Finale
[Warning: General spoilers ahead.] How are we doing, #FROMily? In case you missed it this morning, the very good news is that that cliffhanger will be followed by a second season, which was gifted this morning ahead of the linear broadcast of the finale. I always legitimately appreciate when we…
Elizabeth Saunders Talks EPIX’s From
[Warning: General spoilers ahead.] One of the things that makes EPIX’s From such a fun ride is the abundance of Canadian cast members. Elizabeth Saunders, who plays Donna, is a favorite from her turn on the third season of Mary Kills People [streaming on Global TV in Canada and Roku…
Corteon Moore Talks From “Broken Windows, Open Doors”
[Warning: Spoilers for tonight’s episode.] Tonight’s episode of From had us all in our feels as we learned through flashbacks about the Sophie’s Choice Boyd had to make to save his son, and back in the present as Boyd said his piece with Ellis before heading into the woods with…
Pegah Ghafoori Talks From “All Good Things…”
[Warning: Spoilers for tonight’s episode] Tonight on From, Fatima’s anniversary celebration turned into a Colony House of horrors when a misguided Kevin let his monster bae in and she promptly killed him and left the window open for her crew. While the party devolved into terror and sent everyone running,…
Shaun Majumder Talks From “Book 74”
[Warning: Spoilers for tonight’s episode.] Tonight on EPIX’s From, Father Khatri made a bold move, kidnapping Sara instead of turning her in, and then recognizing her as a vessel for some big messages. That startling realization speaks to him on multiple levels–as a man of faith, a man trapped in…
Avery Konrad Talks About Sara’s Struggle in From “Silhouettes”
[Warning: Spoilers for tonight’s episode.] Over the course of the season so far on From, we’ve witnessed Sara’s battle against the voices telling her to to do terrible things, and tonight we saw her unravel further, threatening the Matthews and lashing out in a moment of terror with horrifying results….
Hannah Cheramy Talks From “Choosing Day”
[Warning: Spoilers for tonight’s episode.] Tonight, on EPIX’s From, the Matthews participate in the show’s version of the sorting hat, choosing where to call home–the town or Colony House. At the end of the episode, Julie makes the decision to split from her family and instead settle in with Fatima…
Ricky He Talks From “The Way Things Are Now”
[Warning: Spoilers for episode 102 of EPIX’s From.] Epix’s new series From is two episodes in and it’s already laying the groundwork for a seriously spooky season. Tonight’s episode demonstrated the careful balance of relief and horror that the show hits, with our characters’ worst fears realized, just not when…
What They Said: Three Revealing Conversations from Survivor’s Remorse “Closure”
WARNING: Spoilers for Survivor’s Remorse “Closure” The latest episode of Starz’s Survivor’s Remorse featured conversations that showed characters really digging deep into their thoughts, emotions and motivations.
Two Takes: The Catch “The Knock-Off”
Who can you trust? If this episode of The Catch was any indication, the answer is just about nobody. Betrayal was running rampant as Felicity (Shivani Ghai) arose from the dead to seduce-con Margot, Gretchen (Maria Thayer, Gotham, The Mindy Project) played gold-hearted Alice 2.0 before swindling Ethan, Tessa jumped…
What They Said: Top 3 Quotable Moments from Preacher “El Valero”
Both Quincannon and Jesse refuse to give up on what they each think is rightfully theirs. While Jesse is struggling to face the consequences of his actions, Quincannon has laid his past demons to rest and is hellbent on moving forward and putting Annville on the map again. Despite a…
What They Said: Favorite Quotes from Supergirl “Worlds Finest”
Oh, Supergirl. That ending was cold. But I can’t hate on you because the latest episode has quickly become one of my favorites.
What They Said: Top 4 Quotable Moments from Black Sails “XXIII”
The dialogue in “XXIII” is phenomenal. It’s always a fun ride when Black Sails carries its viewers along without giving them the chance to catch their breath. When an episode moves at this unforgiving pace, there is no chance for a breather nor is there a respite from the information…
What Lucifer Said: Favorite quotes from Supernatural “O Brother, Where Art Thou?”
Supernatural episodes are almost always funny but thanks to the dialogue and a certain man speaking said dialogue, I laughed a lot during “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” You know, when I wasn’t busy fearing for Sam’s life or wondering what in the world was going on with Dean and…
What They Said: The Flash, “Legends Of Today” and Arrow, “Legends Of Yesterday”
Two nights of Arrow +Â The Flash = what more could we ask for?! I don’t know what it is about blending these shows, but I canâ€™t help but feel that every time they come together, they somehow become greater than the sum of their parts. And thatâ€™s saying a lot…
What they Said: Top 4 Quotable Moments from Graceland “Little Bo Bleep”
Shoot outs. Fake outs. And long-awaited revelations. “Little Bo Bleep” was a jam-packed episode that wrapped up some loose ends and totally frayed others. Â It finally gave us one Sarkissian in jail and pulled back the curtain on Briggs’ master plan, but it also set up Jakes for a world…
What They Said: Favorite Quotes from Poldark “Part 4”
â€œWhat have I told you, I don’t require my wife to crochet and sip tea, but I do require her to remember she’s not a beast of burden.â€ No, Iâ€™m not talking about The Rolling Stones! I have to admit though, just for a second, the lyrics popped into my…
3 Moments of Goodness from Brooklyn Nine-Nine “Johnny and Dora”
The most satisfying part of this season’s finale has to the Jake and Amy kiss. Well, they kiss three times but the last one is the best one — and it means something. The Charles and Rosa dynamic was also great. I love how she’s convinced he doesn’t know anything…