VICE Correspondent Gianna Toboni Investigates the Fight for Marriage Equality in “Church and States” [Exclusive]
When the Supreme Court affirmedÂ marriage equality in the summer of 2015, many in the LGBTQIA+ community celebrated.Â Since the law now protected their right to legally marry their partners, many thought that was the end of this fight. But the religious right has found a way to legally refuse services, housing and/or employment â€“Â even though the highest court in the country has made their position clear. In “Church and States,” VICE correspondent Gianna ToboniÂ meets some of the families who are navigating this new landscape and hears from supporters of religious freedom laws.
I had the chance to talk to GiannaÂ about the urgency of this issue,Â how the people she profiles in the piece came to her attention, how this fight is far from overÂ and more.
TV GOODNESS: I want you do tell me a little bit about your process. At the beginning of this piece youâ€™re at the Supreme Court back in June, talking to couples who are obviously so happy about marriage equality. But what is your process? When do you start doing research? When do you start filming?
Gianna Toboni: “Well before the Supreme Court decision, we knew this was an issue that both sides of the debate were really passionate about and starting to talk about more than they have in years past.
We started researching it, I would say, a few months before the Supreme Court decision. Then when that came down we really started â€“ and, I guess a bit before that â€“ reaching out to people at the center of the issue on both sides to understand the arguments from people on the religious right who were fighting for, for instance, business owners who used the religious freedom argument in order to justify not serving same-sex couples and then also same-sex couples who had been discriminated against and felt like because of a lack of laws in their state they were vulnerable to being discriminated against in the future.
The first step is really understanding what the common arguments are on either side and then from there booking people to film with. It just went from there. We looked for people who werenâ€™t fringe, people who represented other people in the country who feel the same way or were going through the same thing, booking interviews with them, going out in the field and shooting and then, of course, bringing it back and working with editors and some of our senior producers to put the pieces together.”
TV GOODNESS: I like that you talked to so many people and Iâ€™m specifically thinking about the Jorgesons. To thinkÂ itâ€™s possible for the biological mother to have no legal rights to her own child because sheâ€™s gay is so scary. How did that story come to your attention and how did it progress?
Gianna: “We had been in touch with so many organizations and law firms and advocates, different online forums. We tried to reach out to as many people as we could.
This case came to us through a lawyer. Itâ€™s kind of complicated, but there was a case involving a death certificate through the vital statics unit in the state of Texas. It was through that case that we found Leigh and Robin [Jorgeson’s] case.
The lawyer put us in touch with them. We knew they were meant to have their baby on a certain [day]. We were on another shoot and I think they had scheduled their delivery date. We had a week to get to Austin before Robin gave birth and, of course, the baby came a week early. We actually left the [other] shoot and flew straight to Austin. We were there just a day after she gave birth.
I felt like that was an important story because people donâ€™t necessarily think about it before it actually happens and then when it happens the consequences are so great. People across the country who donâ€™t have any real connection to this community donâ€™t understand that this can happen. I felt like it was important to give them a voice and tell their story just to make people aware that some of the laws in place in states across the country are this archaic. They havenâ€™t caught up with this Supreme Court decision.”
TV GOODNESS: Alan Sears was a great get. You brought up some good points and he did a pretty good job of defending himself. Was he a prickly interview?
Gianna: The ADF [Alliance Defending Freedom], theyâ€™re criticized a lot, but I have to say Iâ€™d been in touch with them for months and they are pleasant people to deal with. I give them credit for trusting us enough to put their CEO in an interview chair in front of me. I thought he did a really good job. Heâ€™s a smart guy.
The reason I wanted to talk to him, again to the point I made earlier, is because he is one of the leaders of the movement. Heâ€™s not a fringe guy. He has tens of millions of dollars donated to him each year. He has thousands of followers, if not more. So when we sat down for that interview it was definitely contentious. I felt like I had to bring the argument of the other side and I think he did a fine job of representing his side of the debate.”
TV GOODNESS: I also love that you talked to Senator Cory Booker. Heâ€™s not the first person Iâ€™ve heard liken this fight to the civil rights movement of the â€˜60s. Why was it important for you to have him talk about that?
Gianna: “I had read about that argument before talking to the Senator and, as many people who said this is a valid argument, there were people who said this is not a fair argument. So I was interested to know what the Senator thought.
I think heâ€™s the perfect person to have an opinion on that. It was important to at least ask him if he would make that comparison, which he actually did several times before I even had to ask him. But I thought it was an important point to make because a lot of people, I think, donâ€™t feel the weight of this issue. They think that we have gotten past it, that LGBT rights are no longer something that people have to fight for and in reality thereâ€™s a lot of discrimination.
As Senator Booker said, itâ€™s insidious. Itâ€™s not outward. There arenâ€™t employers who are necessarily saying, â€˜Iâ€™m firing you because youâ€™re gay,â€™ but the person will still get fired and theyâ€™ll never know why. I thought he was very articulate on the issue and made a really good case for why thatâ€™s an appropriate comparison.”
TV GOODNESS: If you were to do a follow-up or a companion piece to this story, what would be your focus and why?
Gianna: “I donâ€™t know. [Pauses.] There was one scene that we didnâ€™t put in that I was so inspired by. Several of us in the room while filming this scene got emotional. We went to a LGBT youth homeless center and we spoke to some of the young people there who had been kicked out of their homes after coming out to their parents.
I talked to the executive director and I said, â€˜Have there been less kids to have shown up here since the Supreme Court decision?â€™ He said, â€˜Our numbers have tripled since the Supreme Court decision.â€™ And the reason was because young people across the country said, â€˜Ok. The highest court in our country says itâ€™s ok to be gay, which means Iâ€™m now comfortable coming out to my parents because itâ€™s ok.â€™ So more kids, I guess, at least in the Southeast came out to their parents, their parents kicked them out and they ended up at the LGBT youth homeless shelter. That made me so sad because they were all struggling, [but]Â had positive attitudes. I hadnâ€™t heard much about that so Iâ€™d be interested to follow up on that.”
TV GOODNESS: After people watch this piece, what is one thing youâ€™re hoping theyâ€™ll take away from it?
Gianna: “The fight for LGBT rights is not over and as [Dana Nessel] said, before we go forward weâ€™re gonna have to take a couple steps back. I think thatâ€™s the biggest thing. This is still a debate thatâ€™s on-going and just because the Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage doesnâ€™t mean that people arenâ€™t living with discrimination.”
TV GOODNESS: I know you got your start at ABC News and you wanted to devote more time to news story outside the mainstream. Why is that important for you?
Gianna: “Thereâ€™s such a freedom in having more time to tell a story. I always felt a sense of guilt when I would interview someone and I knew the piece would only be 3 minutes long and I knew that their story deserved more time than that.
Itâ€™s really a luxury at VICE and for this HBO show that we get to have 15 minutes and sometimes more to give people a voice and to help them tell their stories. Telling stories, and this is something that when I worked at Al Jazeera was a big thing- we should be telling stories that arenâ€™t told anywhere else.
The mainstream is covering A, B and C stories. We should be covering the next four because thereâ€™s so many people around the world who are facing injustices who donâ€™t get a voice and who will never see change in their lives because nobody knows what those injustices are. Itâ€™s our job as journalists and filmmakers to reach out to those people and help them and give them a platform to tell their stories.”
TV GOODNESS: I know you canâ€™t say much, but what else are you working on?
Gianna: “This is always a controversial question because Iâ€™m like, â€˜Can I talk about what hasnâ€™t aired yet?â€™ [Laughs.] Iâ€™ll tell you about one story. A couple years ago I went down to Guantanamo Bay and took a tour of the prison with some of the guards and other military personnel who worked there and then went to Bosnia and met with a former detainee and a former guard in Arizona. Now with the President talking even more frequently about closing the detention center, I think itâ€™s a good time to be talking about that issue again.
Weâ€™ve been filming with detainees in several different countries and giving them a voice to talk about what happened and to talk about how their lives are different now and how theyâ€™ve been affected. Weâ€™ll have a story on Guantanamo Bay, which I think is an important one and canâ€™t be talked about enough.
Edited for space and content.
The other piece in this episode is a follow-up story by VICE correspondent Ben Anderson. He returns to Yemen, where he reported “The Enemy of My Enemy” back in Season 2. In “Return to Yemen,” he documentsÂ the death and destruction visited upon the civilians of Yemen by Saudi Arabia. Last year,Â Yemenâ€™s Houthi rebels launched a massive military campaign that overthrew the Yemeni government and sent the Arabian Peninsula into turmoil. Now, Saudi Arabia â€“ nervous about the insurrection near its southern border â€“ is trying to push the Houthis back with a ruthless bombing campaign. This is one of the worldâ€™s most bloody and underreported conflicts.
VICE airs Fridays at 11/10c on HBO.
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Maahra Hill Talks The Irrational
I’m a Jesse L. Martin stan back to the OG Mothership Law & Order (pour one out for Lennie Brisco, y’all), although I admittedly tapped out on The Flash at a certain point. This season, Martin has been back in his old NBC stomping grounds with The Irrational, a different,…
George R. Olson, Tim Rozon, and Sarah Levy Talk the SurrealEstate S2 Finale
[Spoilers for the SurrealEstate Season 2 finale.] How’s everyone doing after the finale? As we close out the second season of SurrealEstate, some of our merry band of misfits are scattering to the winds–Zooey to law school, Phil to the Vatican, and Augie back to his think tank with Rochelle,…
Previewing SurrealEstate Season 2 Finale + Revisiting the Season with George R. Olson
[Warning; General spoilers ahead.] Strap in, SurrealEstate fam, because we’ve arrived at the Season 2 finale, and it’s a doozy. As we saw in the closing moments of last week’s episode, Susan is back. But because we have one more episode left, it’s not as simple as all that, as…
Tyler Hynes Talks Through His Eight-Film Hallmark Holiday Library
Things you realize when you have to re-record your shows on a new DVR – just how many Hallmark movies your people have done. Fan favorite – and one of ours – Tyler Hynes has done eight Christmas movies for Hallmark Channel and Hallmark Movies & Mysteries since 2018. Alongside…
Spencer Creaghan Talks About Creating SurrealEstate’s Signature Sound
SurrealEstate is winding down its second season, with two episodes left, and just as in Season 1, Spencer Creaghan’s music continues to be a character unto itself. And every week, he shares tidbits with the fans via his s social media channels, something he started to help give them an…
Andrew Walker Talks Christmas Island and the Magical Hallmark Community
[Warning: Spoilers for Christmas Island.] Now that the Screen Actors Guild strike has been resolved, we’re able to resume regularly scheduled programming and interview our favorites and yours. Up first, earlier today, I spoke with Andrew Walker about Christmas Island, which premiered last weekend and encores tonight and through the…
George Olson and Danishka Esterhazy Talk SurrealEstate “I Put a Spell on You”
[Warning: Spoilers for the episode.] Tonight’s fun new SurrealEstate found Luke caught up in an especially bewitching woman, Kay, played by Tara Yelland, Susan trapped in her house, and Zooey learning the ropes. In the next part of my conversation with showrunner George R. Olson and producing director Danishka Esterhazy,…
Danishka Esterhazy Talks SurrealEstate: “The Butler Didn’t”
[Warning: General spoilers for the episode]. Tonight’s new SurrealEstate, “The Butler Didn’t,” follows the team as they investigate the years-earlier mysterious death of a woman whose ghost now reenacts her hanging by dropping over the banister from the second floor to terrify anyone on the landing or at the bottom…
Scott McCord and Elizabeth Saunders Talk the From Season 2 finale
[Warning: Spoilers for the season finale.] How’s everyone doing after that finale? While we wait and wonder and hope for a third season announcement, soon, here’s what Scott McCord and Elizabeth Saunders had to say about their parts of the finale, and where they hope they get to go next….
Scott McCord and Elizabeth Saunders Talk From Season 2 + A Season Finale Preview
[Warning: General spoilers ahead.] It all comes down this, #FROMily. As Sunday’s episode wraps up Season 2, we begin with the aftermath of the terrifying onset of seemingly simultaneous attacks on Julie, Marielle, and Randall, which accelerate the “We gotta get out of this place” of it all. Sara comes…
What They Said: Three Revealing Conversations from Survivor’s Remorse “Closure”
WARNING: Spoilers for Survivor’s Remorse “Closure” The latest episode of Starz’s Survivor’s Remorse featured conversations that showed characters really digging deep into their thoughts, emotions and motivations.
Two Takes: The Catch “The Knock-Off”
Who can you trust? If this episode of The Catch was any indication, the answer is just about nobody. Betrayal was running rampant as Felicity (Shivani Ghai) arose from the dead to seduce-con Margot, Gretchen (Maria Thayer, Gotham, The Mindy Project) played gold-hearted Alice 2.0 before swindling Ethan, Tessa jumped…
What They Said: Top 3 Quotable Moments from Preacher “El Valero”
Both Quincannon and Jesse refuse to give up on what they each think is rightfully theirs. While Jesse is struggling to face the consequences of his actions, Quincannon has laid his past demons to rest and is hellbent on moving forward and putting Annville on the map again. Despite a…
What They Said: Favorite Quotes from Supergirl “Worlds Finest”
Oh, Supergirl. That ending was cold. But I can’t hate on you because the latest episode has quickly become one of my favorites.
What They Said: Top 4 Quotable Moments from Black Sails “XXIII”
The dialogue in “XXIII” is phenomenal. It’s always a fun ride when Black Sails carries its viewers along without giving them the chance to catch their breath. When an episode moves at this unforgiving pace, there is no chance for a breather nor is there a respite from the information…
What Lucifer Said: Favorite quotes from Supernatural “O Brother, Where Art Thou?”
Supernatural episodes are almost always funny but thanks to the dialogue and a certain man speaking said dialogue, I laughed a lot during “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” You know, when I wasn’t busy fearing for Sam’s life or wondering what in the world was going on with Dean and…
What They Said: The Flash, “Legends Of Today” and Arrow, “Legends Of Yesterday”
Two nights of Arrow +Â The Flash = what more could we ask for?! I don’t know what it is about blending these shows, but I canâ€™t help but feel that every time they come together, they somehow become greater than the sum of their parts. And thatâ€™s saying a lot…
What they Said: Top 4 Quotable Moments from Graceland “Little Bo Bleep”
Shoot outs. Fake outs. And long-awaited revelations. “Little Bo Bleep” was a jam-packed episode that wrapped up some loose ends and totally frayed others. Â It finally gave us one Sarkissian in jail and pulled back the curtain on Briggs’ master plan, but it also set up Jakes for a world…
What They Said: Favorite Quotes from Poldark “Part 4”
â€œWhat have I told you, I don’t require my wife to crochet and sip tea, but I do require her to remember she’s not a beast of burden.â€ No, Iâ€™m not talking about The Rolling Stones! I have to admit though, just for a second, the lyrics popped into my…
3 Moments of Goodness from Brooklyn Nine-Nine “Johnny and Dora”
The most satisfying part of this season’s finale has to the Jake and Amy kiss. Well, they kiss three times but the last one is the best one — and it means something. The Charles and Rosa dynamic was also great. I love how she’s convinced he doesn’t know anything…